Today you know that what is the best Phillips Sonicare ProtectiveClean toothbrush and the battle of 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100. Let’s see who is the winner of this Battle.
When it comes to Phillips, they never miss a quality toothbrush. The complete series of Sonicare is full of products that meet the diverse needs of customers. They are approved by ADA (American Dental Association) too! Therefore, you are always sure that you are getting a quality product.
There are so many options in this series to make people’s heads turn. Each one with its unique set of benefits and advantages that differentiate it. One is never at a loss with a product.
However, if we have to choose and select a product of many, I thought we should choose some of the brushes, try them and make a comparison. This is the only way to be clear about things and select one of the many. That’s the whole reason for this Phillips Sonicare 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100 face to face.
Let me tell you first about my own experience with these tooth cleaners. Later, I will analyze their differences and how one model may or may not replace the other.
Sonicare 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100 Overview
- 1 Sonicare 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100 Overview
- 2 In-Depth Sonicare ProtectiveClean Toothbrush Comparison Table
- 2.1 Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean Toothbrush Review & Comparison: 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100
- 2.2 Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100 Review
- 2.3 Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 5100 Review- Gum Health
- 2.4 Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 6100 Review- Whitening Rechargeable electric toothbrush
- 2.5 What Are the Similarities Between the Brushes?
- 2.6 Phillips Sonicare 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100: Which One Wins the Battle?
- 2.7 Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100 vs 5100
- 2.8 Sonicare ProtectiveClean 5100 vs 6100- The Battle is Neck and Neck
- 2.9 Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100 vs 6100
- 3 Which One Should You Pick?
The needs and desires of each are different, but it is the 4100 which, for the most part, is the best choice.
It has all the essential features of an electric toothbrush, as well as a few others for good measure, all at a very reasonable price.
It’s not too complicated, well designed and, of course, does a fantastic job of cleaning your teeth.
The 5100 offers some extra cleaning modes and a carrying case. This is worth the extra expense for those who are often traveling overnight to different locations.
The 6100 has a lot to offer, but the extras it offers are not necessarily necessary or sufficient to part with the extra money.
In-Depth Sonicare ProtectiveClean Toothbrush Comparison Table
|Model||Philips Sonicare 4100||Philips Sonicare 5100||Philips Sonicare 6100|
|Modes||Clean||Clean, Gum Care, Whitening||Clean, Gum Care, Whitening|
|Replacement Head Reminder||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Illuminated Display||Handle shows battery status||Battery status & brush head reminder||Battery status & brush head reminder|
|Brush Heads Included||Optimal Plaque Control||Optimal Gum Care||Protective Clean, DiamondClean|
|Price||Check price||Check price||Check price|
Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean Toothbrush Review & Comparison: 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100
Philips Sonicare’s line of toothbrushes ProtectiveClean should focus on certain areas of concern. It converges on those fields while providing a gentle brushing experience. Each model, from 4100 to 6100, presents the motto “He does it gently”.
We have made a comparison of these new models. The 4100, 5100 and 6100 models have some excellent features that are available as part of all Sonicare toothbrushes because the company is known to them.
This new line of toothbrushes has some really interesting features unique to each toothbrush, which is why we have broken them down for you.
The ProtectiveClean 4100 is focused on reducing plate. There is a cleaning mode with the 4100. It is intended to directly impact the amount of plaque that is removed between the teeth and below the gum line. It has 7 times more plaque removal than manual toothbrushes.
Sonicare has sound technology in its toothbrushes. You will get all the benefits you expect.
There is a Smartimer to encourage you to brush for the recommended dentist for two minutes. Every time you brush, that Smartimer will keep you on track.
The Easy Start function is ideal for those who have never used an electric toothbrush.
It will start at lower power and slowly increase in power as you get used to the brushing experience. Over time, it will help you take full advantage of the sonic brushing technology.
The ProtectiveClean 4100 comes with an optimal plate control brush head. This brush head will help to focus your brushing for those who have a problem with plaque buildup. It will do it in a gentle way. This line of toothbrushes from Philips focuses on providing its benefits smoothly.
The 4100 electric toothbrush has all the great characteristics of the Sonicare brand. It comes with Smartimer, pacemaker and a long-lasting battery. For each charge, you get 2 weeks of battery life. While this toothbrush does not have a travel case, it can still travel quite well.
The Easy Start of the 4100 provides smooth power just like the toothbrush itself. This line focuses on providing benefits smoothly. The toothbrush does not allow a lot of pressure on the teeth while you learn, either. That can be a problem for those who are moving from a manual toothbrush to an electric toothbrush.
The ProtectiveClean 4100 also has BrushSync technology that calculates the pressure you have been using most of the brushing time. We will notify you when it is time to change the brush head.
What could be better?
There is no travel case with this toothbrush.
What I liked about Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100
- It is a simple device to operate; I did not have to go through several ways to get the right one.
- The 4100 warns you when you have finished cleaning a quarter of your mouth.
- BrushSync lets you know when is the right time to change the brush head to maintain performance
- I liked the fact that Sonicare 4100 automatically shuts down when people end up with that.
- You have different colors at your disposal to choose one. In addition, it is comfortable to hold it in your hands.
What I did not like about Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100
- The pressure sensor does not blink and has no visible light. You have to go with vibrations.
- The heads of the brushes are expensive when it comes to Sonicare 4100. You will have your hands full.
- I expected a travel bag to hold the components of the box securely.
The 5100 concentrates on gentle but effective gum health. There are three cleaning modes. Clean is what you would normally use. Gum care is the focus of this toothbrush. The white is meant to whiten your teeth.
With this toothbrush, you will get the Smartimer to help you stay on track. Dentists recommend two minutes of brushing.
The timer will notify you after the time has passed. The pacemaker in this brush will make sure that it is also moving from one quadrant to another in the two minutes assigned.
This toothbrush kit includes the handle of the toothbrush and an Optimal Gum Care brush head. It will focus on providing focused attention on the gums for healthier gums.
Along with the focused brush head, the 5100 comes with bits you will need to travel with your toothbrush. There’s no reason why you should leave this toothbrush at home when you’re on the road. It comes with a travel case to keep your toothbrush clean and free of dirt. The charging base is also compact.
The 5100 has a pressure sensor to make sure you’re not brushing too much. With 31,000 strokes per minute, there’s no reason to press down to brush your teeth.
As far as the 5100 is concerned, it is a beautiful toothbrush with many features that make it a great benefit. The way you focus on the health of the gums will ensure that your gums will always be at the peak of good health. You could even reverse some serious gum problems when you focus on that area.
It is a definite advantage to have a pressure sensor. Most people who have problems with the gums will work hard and give a more vigorous cleaning to the gums. It’s the right idea, but it can really do a lot of damage. It is better to let the sonic action do all the work. The alert in this brush will help re-train your brushing habits.
This toothbrush is safe for the gums, as well as any dental work you may have. Braces, fillings, and veneers will always be safe with the sonic toothbrush. It will not alter your dental work.
What could be better?
The 5100 does not have BrushSync synchronization to recognize the type of brush head that is being used.
What I liked about Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 5100
- This wonderful toothbrush comes with Clean, White and Gum Care modes for people to use.
- You can control the wear of the brush head. 5100 will tell you when it is time to change.
- Users have a time monitoring system in place that tells you when to continue or stop brushing.
- BrushSync informs you when your head is about to expire so that people can buy new ones on time.
- A rugged travel bag is offered with the model. Prevents damage from accidental falls.
What I did not like about Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 5100
- I would have liked a visible pressure sensor instead of one that vibrates. It is easy to get lost sometimes.
- The heads of the replacement brushes are not so cheap when you compare the price of the main unit.
The ProtectiveClean 6100 sets its focus on whitening. It provides a whiter smile in just 1 week compared to a manual toothbrush. There is a whitening mode as well as a cleaning mode, which is for daily cleaning. The toothbrush also comes with a way of caring for the gums.
There is a pressure sensor in this handle that will alert you when you brush too hard. Removing plaque and stains is not about the pressure you exert on the brush against your teeth.
It’s the sonic technology that makes the difference in your smile. There are 31,000 brush strokes to remove stains without pressure.
Included with the handle is the Diamond Clean cleaning head. The handle is compatible with all the brush heads of the Sonicare line. The 3 cleaning modes will be matched with the correct brush head due to BrushSync technology. It will also notify you when it is time to change the brush for a new one. That happens approximately every 3 to 4 months.
The 6100 has a battery charge indicator on the handle. The toothbrush can hold a charge for 2 weeks, so it is important that you can see when it needs to be recharged. You may forget to charge after a week or more. The charger and the travel case are included in this kit.
As for the 6100, it is an excellent toothbrush to concentrate on whitening teeth. If you want a brighter, white smile, it comes with the right brush head for the job. The cleaning and whitening mode is designed to remove stains and plaque. The plaque can soften your smile as much as the spots.
Like the other Sonicare toothbrushes, it comes with a Smartimer and a pacemaker to warn you about the proper brushing time. A total of 2 minutes of brushing is encouraged. It may be longer than you expect, so it’s good to have the timer.
The 6100 starts easily with easy start mode. You also have the possibility to choose an intensity setting. There are 3 settings for you to choose with this toothbrush.
What could be better?
The intensity can be high for beginners who have never used an electric toothbrush.
What I liked about Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100
- I found three different cleaning modes very useful and a good addition to the model itself.
- In addition to that, people can use three intensity levels that adjust automatically for cleaning.
- The QuadPacer function lets you know when it’s time to move to other parts of your mouth.
- You have the smart timer that tells people when they have finished brushing. It goes off later.
- The BrushSync system tells the user when is the optimal time to change the brush head.
- You get the pressure sensor too. It tells people if they are putting too much pressure on the gums.
- I loved the travel bag and the portable charger that accompanies it. Expand my options on vacation.
What I did not like about Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100
- As I keep saying over and over again, additional brush heads are more expensive than some of the other brands.
- We are talking about Sonicare 6100 and manufacturers have not yet put a visible pressure sensor.
- The price keeps it in the middle range. You pay the cost but receive small improvements compared to it.
What Are the Similarities Between the Brushes?
As all these brushes belong to different series of Sonicare (4000, 5000 and 6000, respectively), I did not compare these thoughts, they will be similar to each other. To my surprise, I found that each of these models was identical to the others while using it. Let’s document the similarities before going to filter the differences.
- You will find BrushSync technology working on these three models. It is an indicator that indicates the state of the brush head. When the indicator turns red, you must change the head.
- The pressure sensor is another thing that is common in all three brushes. The sensor tells someone if he/she is applying too much pressure on the brush head. When the pressure is more than required, the brush vibrates and warns you.
- The lithium-ion battery is another common thing. This battery can hold the charge for two weeks on average. The LED indicator shows the amount of charge you have left to work. You have the brush holder that acts as the loading dock.
- QuadPacer and the Smart Timer are the two types of timers that tell you how long you should brush each side and the total brushing time you need to clean your teeth. In fact, the machine switches off automatically after brushing for two minutes. It is 30 seconds to brush a quarter of the mouth.
- All brushes have soft bristles. The bristles are soft for the gums, teeth, veneers, crowns, appliances and other dental procedures. As a result, the mouth, gums, and teeth remain protected at all times.
Phillips Sonicare 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100: Which One Wins the Battle?
Now that I have been supporting my experience in the use of these three products and I have talked about the similarities, it is time to analyze the differences in detail. But comparing these three products at the same time is a bit difficult. Let’s do it in pairs.
That’s the summary of all the toothbrushes in this new ProtectiveClean line. Now is the time to delve into the differences from one model to another.
Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100 vs 5100
The 4100 and 5100 models have some of the same features, as they are available as part of the Sonicare line. Both have a Smartimer. Help the person to brush to stick to the 2 minutes of cleaning recommended by dentists.
It is assumed that brushing two minutes occurs twice a day. It is unlikely that many people who use a manual brush are brushing long enough. It’s longer than you expect without a timer to keep you on track.
Once the two minutes have elapsed, an alert will sound that tells the user that he can do the brushing.
You can always continue brushing if you want. It may also be time to change from regular cleaning to a deeper cleaning.
After the first two minutes, you can change from cleaning to whitening or caring for the gums. The choice is yours and is based on the toothbrush model you choose.
There is also a Quadpacer that will beep to let you know that you should switch to a new quadrant of your mouth. The 4 quadrants should get 30 full seconds of brushing. If you want to use the Quadpacer, you should track the part of the mouth that has been brushed. The four need equal attention.
Both toothbrushes have a battery charging light. They allow 14 days of battery life per charge. The Li-Ion battery has a charge for a long time, but it is important to be aware of the charge. You do not want to keep a dead toothbrush.
The 4100 and the 5100 also have a pressure sensor. It will prevent you from exerting undue pressure on the teeth when brushing. Since both toothbrushes have 31,000 strokes per minute, there is no reason to rub the teeth.
The rubbing leads to the backward movement of the gums. It can also cause problems with scraping your tooth enamel. Enamel protects the teeth and should not be removed through cleaning.
Each toothbrush is guaranteed by the company for 2 years. The warranty will cover serious problems resulting from manufacturing. It will not cover the problems of abuse and maintenance derived from the owner of the toothbrush.
The ProtectiveClean models have the motto of providing a gentle cleaning experience. With that in mind, there is an easy start mode on the 4100 as well as the 5100.
Both have a brush head included in the kit. The 4100 gets an optimal plate control brush head. The 5100 gets the Optimal Gum Care brush head.
The BrushSync replacement reminder will really calculate how long the brush head has been. It will track the frequency of use and the pressure used during brushing. All that information will be used to recommend once the brush head should be replaced.
The 4100 is the first in the line of ProtectiveClean toothbrushes. It is the one with the most basic characteristics, too. There is only one cleaning mode compared to the 3 cleaning modes available in the 5100.
The 5100 is intended to concentrate on the care of the gums, so it has the brush head included in your kit. There is also a way that narrows in the gums.
As for the 4100, that model has a plate cleaning mode focused on eliminating as much plate as possible.
The ProtectiveClean 4100 has Clean as the only mode available. The 5100 has cleaning, white and gum care modes. There is also a light on the handle that will show the mode that is being used on the 5100. The 4100 has this icon illuminated.
The 5100 comes with a travel case, which is not included in the kit for the 4100.
Sonicare ProtectiveClean 5100 vs 6100-
The Battle is Neck and Neck
First, we will cover the areas where 5100 and 6100 are equal. They have the same number of cleaning modes. There are 3 in each toothbrush. They bought have the cleaning mode, which provides a daily and complete cleaning.
There is a whitening mode, which will eliminate stains. Whitening mode focuses on removing stains from things like wine and coffee. Many people need this type of stain removal since they drink coffee and wine regularly. It will also whiten your smile by eliminating food stains like those you consume.
The plate of the teeth can also be removed. That can also affect the whitening process. Without using any type of whitening toothpaste or whitening strips, you can see a significant difference in whiteness only with brushing.
Finally, there is the gum care mode that will massage the gums.
Diseases such as gingivitis can be reversed with the attention paid to the area. The way of care of the gums applies 31,000 brushstrokes to the gums. You can remove the plaque and restore health to the gums.
Many people brush too aggressively, which can cause the gums to recede. The effects of aggressive brushing can be reversed quickly. Especially when you switch from manual brushing to sonic technology.
Each cleaning mode has an icon on the handle itself. You can see how you are looking at the illuminated handle. On the handle, it will also be easy to see the charge light of the battery. It will notify you when it is time to recharge.
There is a Smartimer available in these two models, such as the 4100. The timer may seem like a small feature, but it is vital for good oral hygiene. Your dentist recommends that you take two minutes to brush your teeth twice a day. Two minutes can be much longer than you think without time. It is likely that you are not spending enough time brushing.
The 5100 and the 6100 have the Quadpacer included in the handle. It will be a pulse to let you know when it is time to move. You will have to pay attention to the areas you have done previously to make sure you get them all.
Each toothbrush model has a pressure sensor. Sonicare understands how important it is to maintain gentle pressure and allow the sonic nature of the brush to do the job. You should never scrape or rub your teeth and gums to clean them.
On both toothbrushes, you will find the BrushSync reminder for when it is time to replace the brush head. It is based on some factors, such as the time spent brushing and pressing while brushing.
The 5100 is focused on the care of the gums, while the 6100 is intended for whitening. For that reason, the two come with different brush heads. The 5100 has the Optimal Gum Care brush head while the 6100 has the DiamondClean.
As for the functions that are available in the 6100 compared to the 5100, you will find the pairing mode. When you have bought more brush heads, they will automatically combine with the correct mode.
The 6100 also has 3 brush intensities. Those are not available in 5100. The intensities are designed for your personal comfort. You can choose the speed (low, medium or high) that best suits you.
Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100 vs 6100
The first on the line and the last one on the line, the 4100 versus the 6100, is where you’ll find most of the differences. However, there are still many similarities. All the great things you will find with the Sonicare line are available here.
The Smartimer is the first characteristic that is the same. The brushing time recommended by dentists for two minutes is vital. They have been telling us for years and years that brushing for two minutes is very important for their oral hygiene. However, we still do not spend enough time brushing.
The timer will notify you when the required two minutes have passed.
You can not guess how much time is left. You will notice that when you are brushing, you would have thought that you had finished before what the timer indicates.
In the 4100 and 6100, there is also the Quadpacer.
This pacemaker will pulse when it is time to change sections of the mouth. You should think of your mouth in 4 quadrants to make sure you are hitting each area.
The two models also have a pressure sensor. It is a standard addition to many of Sonicare toothbrushes. They understand that you should never rub the tooth to remove plaque or food.
It is unnecessary anyway. The sonic technology will make your teeth incredibly clean. Rubbing with force is a bad habit of manual brushing. Toothbrushes will alert you to the fact that you are pushing too hard. It may take some time to retrain to brush properly, but the 4100 and 6100 will help with that.
The battery life is 14 days for the toothbrush 4100 and 6100. You can fully charge it and have 2 full weeks of brushing before worrying about a refill. Makes Sonicare toothbrushes a great travel toothbrush. You do not have to give up electric toothbrushes just because you’re going on vacation.
Now, it’s time to go into the differences between 4100 and 6100. There are a few. The number of cleaning modes is a big difference. The 6100 has 3 modes; Cleaning, whitening, and care of the gums. The 4100 only has one mode, which is cleanliness.
The 4100 does not have any brushing intensity mode. Both have an easy start mode that will start slowly to help beginners get used to electric brushing. The 6100 has separate configurations that you can choose for yourself from low to medium to high.
As for BrushSync, both have a reminder of when the brush head should be replaced. The 6100 goes one step further. The BrushSync pairing mode will change the mode automatically according to the brush head you are using.
You can purchase additional brush heads for both models, but the 6100 is the only one that will recognize the brush head. It will switch to the correct mode automatically depending on the head chosen.
The 4100 comes with the Optimal Plaque Control brush head. The 6100 comes with the DiamondClean brush head. The pairing mode would choose to whiten for the DiamondClean brush head of the 6100.
The 6100 comes with a travel case but the 4100 does not. You can take both easily on vacation with you, but you will have to make arrangements for a space in your bag for the 4100.
Which One Should You Pick?
I’d be frank with you: as I write an article like the comparison battle of Phillips Sonicare 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100, I usually discard the oldest model. In this case, it turns out to be one of the 4000 series.
BUT, When you want a complete brushing solution within a tight price range, Sonicare ProtectiveClean is your best solution.
ProtectiveClean 5100 is for smart people. You have access to additional brushing modes. People can experiment with these modes and create an appropriate one for their teeth. Also, the design is better and it has to be with additional control buttons and LED indicators. Oh, and you have a travel case to boot.
If you have money and do not mind spending a few extra dollars, get Sonicare 6100. The different AKA intensity levels are obviously useful. The product combines them with different ways of brushing.
These modes have shorter or longer brushing intervals depending on which one you are using. In general, it is a great product, no matter how you look at it. However, the difference between the previous model is only in the intensities and in some design choices. That is all!
Conclusion-Sonicare 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100
This is a complete and deep breakdown between the three ProtectiveClean toothbrushes. The models 4100, 5100 and 6100 have many similarities, but in the differences, you will find the right toothbrush for your needs.
Each of them focuses on a different area, from the care of the gums to the removal of plaque and whitening. That could be enough to help you make your choice. If not, the comparison chart should help you make a firm decision.
As for our recommendations, we would choose the Philips Sonicare 6100. It has all the best common characteristics for all Sonicare toothbrushes. There are advances that make it worthwhile to choose from. Brush intensities and BrushSync technology are a great advantage for a sonic toothbrush.